« Bad Teachers ... and Bad Principals | Main | For those who are missing "Dad" »

Best Way to Close the Gap? Hold the Top Back!

There are significant dangers in the current focus on closing the racial gap in achievement scores (thanks N2P!). The clearest danger is that the easiest way to do this is by holding the potential high achievers back! This can happen through just not providing appropriate challenges for high-achieving students, or by teaching in a way that is effective for low achievers, but not for middle and high achievers (a value-added shed pattern). States and systems that make this focus without value-added analysis of achievement scores on a prior-achievement basis run a real risk of cheating higher-achieving kids -- a deficit from which they likely will not recover.

TrackBack

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.typepad.com/t/trackback/24683/842890

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference Best Way to Close the Gap? Hold the Top Back!:

Comments

Hi, Tom! I know you from EducationNews.org.

Good piece. I know NC has done some work with the Sanders version of value-added. Have you looked into any of their data?

It's quite clear that great teaching for low-achieving students is not necessarily great teaching for higher achievers. I'm just glad that some of the insights that have grown out of value-added have so quicly permeated the education world that folks are rapidly identifying this risk. Now we'll see if they're prepared to do something effective about it.

Re: Best Way to Close the Gap? Hold the Top Back!

I don't think holding above average students back is anyone's intent. But that result maybe inevitable given the incentive structure of NCLB. See results for North Carolina, a high stakes testing pioneer in my piece below.

No Child Left Behind and Unintended Consequences
Letter, News-Topic (Caldwell County, NC)
June 12, 2004
Tom Shuford (retired public school teacher)
http://www.educationnews.org/no_child_left_behind_and_uninten.htm

The comments to this entry are closed.

Thriving in Law School Signup

* required

*

*

*

*

*



*



Email Marketing by VerticalResponse

Positive Psychology Bookshelf