« Tennessee's Data Once Again Crucially Missing | Main | Wolfe at Quebec »

Anything but White and Western

Update 8/25/2004: Welcome Joanne Jacob readers. In a way, I'm sorry this is the first post you'll read on this site. It is far more tart than my norm. See the follow-up in AWW, Part 2 for more perspective. Look around, or visit ShearonforSchools.com for more on my ideas about improving public schools.

hipteacher posts about getting ready for her first year as a teacher this year, including a class of 11th grade World Literature:

I am using my mini-vacation before school to read up on "world" literature. My new textbooks won't arrive until about 5 weeks after school starts and I'm not familiar with much of the material. The world is awfully big, and I haven't been exposed to near enough of it. My big sister lent me a copy of her Norton World Lit anthology that she used in college which was published in 1985. There is only about two selections in the entire book that I don't consider white and western, and therefore, not really what I want my class to be about.

Bad news: she came out of college and ed school unprepared.

Good news: she knows it, and she's doing something about it.

Bad news: she's thinks teaching the works of white westerners is a bad thing.

Bad news: she apparently has no clue of the ramifications of this statement.

On balance: bad news.

TrackBack

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.typepad.com/t/trackback/24683/956645

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference Anything but White and Western:

» Welcome, teacher from joannejacobs.com
Via Eduwonk, I've discovered Hip Teacher, written by a brand-new high school English teacher. She's teaching in an inner-city school, but I can't figure out where. Dave Shearon thinks Hip Teacher should include some white westerners in her World Litera... [Read More]

Comments

Dave, my apologies. I had no desire to turn this into a name calling contest.

"out of stick-in-the-mud, closed minded, quick to judge dolts. Remind you of anyone, SSM?"

As I am none of those, I can only assume you are describing yourself. Please don't assume that you know me based on the content of one comment.

It is clear that I was making a generalization and not a direct attack on your friend so please refrain from attacking me.

Rereading my comment, I'm not sure that it actually makes sense. What I was trying to say is that I would hope that anyone assigned to teach "world literature" for the first time would at some point in July think to themselves "I am supposed to have mastered all the literature of the world? I'm not ready for this." And if they haven't felt overwhelmed by that at least momentarily, they aren't thinking about what they're doing.

And I have a nice healthy A/B GPA.

Just for the record, my Masters degree is in English, not Education.

SMM: last time I checked, someone who can get a "5" on THREE AP tests without even having been in the AP classes while in High School is not a "C" student (or teacher). This woman we are discssing is not only a dear friend, but also an inspired and inspiring person. I wish I could have had classes with teachers as open and thoughtful as she is. Unfortunately I was usually forced to squeeze something that resembled "education" out of stick-in-the-mud, closed minded, quick to judge dolts. Remind you of anyone, SSM?
Also, how come no one is up in arms about the fact that she won't even have TEXTBOOKS until half-way through the first semester?! Even if she were a second-rate teacher, how the heck do you expect her to be able to teach without BOOKS?

Ah, you beat me to the punch, Will.

I'd be more worried about the hubris of a first year teach who was deluded enough to think that they had a comprehensive grasp of "world literature," unless they had a masters in comp lit under their belt.

Also, unless every literature class in her school is called "world literature," it would seem that the intent of the class is to highlight literature other than what they cover in American/Brit Lit., so her desire to find non-Western texts doesn't seem so much like political correctness run amok.

Hopefully they'll read some Borges and Kafka though.

With all due respect, I think this is a total misread of her post. If you've read her blog on a regular basis as I have, I think it's pretty obvious that this is a young teacher with a passion to teach. Further, I'd wager she's smarter than most of the new teachers out there. Nowhere does she say teaching white Westerners is a bad thing. Those authors aren't relevant to that particular class. There are no inherent messages or "ramifications" that I can see. We have all sorts of classes that focus on other ethnicities and other genres. Why is that a problem?

She sounds like every other "C" student teacher being pumped out of Education Schools.

I wonder when public schools will wise up and start following the private school example and hire those with degrees in the field they will be teaching rather than those with some broad useless degree in Education. They might as well have a generic Liberal Arts degree.

The comments to this entry are closed.

Thriving in Law School Signup

* required

*

*

*

*

*



*



Email Marketing by VerticalResponse

Positive Psychology Bookshelf