1864 was my year yesterday from two directions. First, I listened to most of The Dahlgren Affair on tape as I drove back from Memphis. Very interesting, and well done. Many similarities to today. Pundits and editorialists raving like lunatics on both sides. Peace Democrats in the North ready for the country to lose in order to beat a Republican President. The New York Times resorting to making things up when mere embellishment proved insufficient. Letters and diaries serve as the blogs of that day, recording the contemporaneous thoughts of individuals in different circumstances and from varying walks of life. Then, last night, T, Tyler & i watched Cold Mountain.
From The Dahlgren Affair: mystery, intrigue, corruption North and South, a rich man's war, and wonderful "What if's?" For example, what if Gen. Kilpatrick (a/k/a "Kill Cavalry") hadn't lost his nerve after his plan succeeded in putting his force of 3000+ cavalry on the outskirts of a virtually undefended Richmond on March 1, 1864. What if he'd ordered a charge instead of cautious approach on foot that allowed home guard defenders to gather and put up enough resistance to make him lose his nerve completely and order a retreat? What if he'd liberated the prisoners at Liddy Prison and Belle Island? Seems likely he could have, even with Colonel Dahlgren's mischance of a guide who got lost keeping him from entering Richmond from the South. I'm hoping to get some answers to the Dahlgren mystery. Highly recommended.
From Cold Mountain: Gripping movie. The opening scenes of the sapping of the Confederate lines during the seige of Petersburg reminded me of The Guns of the South, whch references that event. What a destructive, brutal, costly war. What a price this country has paid because of slavery. How is it that we can even question the need to confront depraved domination and subjugation of human beings, whether in Iraq or Darfur? No, we can't fight every battle that needs fighting all at once. But, the civilized world should no longer consider it acceptable to stand by while criminal gangs loot and rape a country or an ethnic group simply because they have been able to cloak themselves in the trappings of a "government."
P.S. Amazing what the internet provides. I did catch the anti-war slant of Cold Mountain, but I missed the anti-male bias. An Amazon reviewer didn't. He writes:
Recent Comments